Why XD over Glock?

TxShooter · Oct 16, 2012

Why did you choose XD over Glock?

theoldman · Oct 16, 2012

Never chose.. Have both and love both. Guess I'm kinda wierd cause I can shoot both comfortably ..

RUT · Oct 16, 2012

What the "Old Man" said. I like 'em both and shoot 'em both.

yogiboobooranger · Oct 16, 2012

The only XD I chose over a Glock is the new XD-S. Saw it, held it and had to have it. Much smaller than my G36 which I had just purchased a few days before I got the XD-S. It is actually the only XD I have for the moment..but have had many in the past. I will have more soon though.

SeventiesWreckers · Oct 16, 2012

I like my G21 just fine, no complaints at all. It's set up with a Viridian X5L that fits it perfectly, and is factory black. Works fine as a night gun at home, & for outside when I walk the property. The XDM is just a couple ounces lighter, no laser/taclite, and is narrower in the slide. It makes a nice carry gun that way, so that's what I take when I go out. They both shoot great, I just use them for different chores.

Gallows · Oct 16, 2012

Never tried a Glock. I handled a S&W MP40, Sig 9mm and a Remington 9mm before going with the XD platform.

SHOOTER13 · Oct 16, 2012

Own a Glock 30SF with no complaints and have my sights set on a new XDs...

boombah · Oct 16, 2012

Have to say I love em both!! Glock 30SF and XDM 5.25, XDS .45!!

Terry · Oct 17, 2012

I too own a Glock 29. I love the 10mm BUT IT IS NOT AN XD.

mosin · Oct 17, 2012

Had an engineer on a ship i was on talk about his XD all the time. I was planning a kayak trip through the everglades and wanted a .45, so i bought the XD.

opaww · Oct 17, 2012

I like them both but the reason I got the XD was because it was $300 and never shot, came with everything

ajb · Oct 17, 2012

The Glock grip angle doesn't work for me. I have to force my wrist down to see the sights.

Jamie · Oct 17, 2012

I have both too but XD's just fit my hand better

Woody · Oct 17, 2012

I prefer the angle of the Grip and the 1911 style grip saftey

chuckusaret · Oct 17, 2012

I chose the XD SC over the glock because of the grip angle, the safeties, but the reliability/failures of the Glock was the key issue. I have 6,000 plus rounds down the pipe of my XD without a failure of any kind.

stoney · Oct 17, 2012

I never cared for Glock-I like the looks & feel of an XD period.I got an XD Service a couple of months after my wife bought herself an XD .40 SC. I sent it Springer Precision and had the grip cut down to except SC mags.I'm happy!

Balota · Oct 17, 2012

A buddy of mine wanted to try out some 40 cal subcompacts. We went to my range and rented a Glock (don't remember the number). We both tried it. We both hated it. Each shot stung like whacking a concrete parking lot with a baseball bat. After 5 rounds my wrist was numb up to the elbow. I'm not a Glock-hater, but that particular gun was just painful.

We took the Glock back to the counter and rented the XDSC 40 cal. That had plenty of recoil also, but it didn't hurt like the Glock did. I think he decided to move up to the Compact size and he's still trying guns before buying.

JimA · Oct 17, 2012

I just don't like the grips on a Glock. They are great guns and very reliable, but feel funny in my hands. I have a G20SF that I shoot OK, but it never feels as good as the grip angle on a 1911,XD,FN,SR9, or M&P.

bowserb · Oct 17, 2012

Had a Glock. Had an XD9-SC. Now have an XDM45 4.5". XD/XDM is better for me because:

Grip safety, where Glock has no safety (no matter what they claim).
Loaded chamber indicator is MUCH more obvious than Glock's.
Cocked striker indicator.
Looks better, although this is not a deal maker/breaker

All that said, if the Glock 38 were a .45ACP instead of .45GAP, I'd be on that in a minute and get a 3rd party thumb safety. Glock's mid size pistols are tops. G19, G23, G32, G38--very light, longer grip than the subcompacts, 4" barrels, easy to conceal. I wish SA had that size pistol. Like most mfrs, SA's compacts have too little grip and too little mag capacity for me.

dondavis3 · Oct 17, 2012

I own Glocks (2) & S&W M&P's (3) and XDm's (2).

I like them all

But I do not believe that Glock have kept pace with the marketplace.

Here's what I mean:

Plastic sights vs metal sights
Grip angle
decent backstrap system
decent slide serrations/grippiness.
Full ambi.
Removable backstraps. (not til Gen 4)
Grip angle. (oh I said that )
Texturing that doesn't rip skin off
Stainless steel slide
Grip Safety
Loaded chamber indicator or hole
Cocked striker indicator
stainless steel sub-chassis
beefed up spring box (what Glock calls a guide ring)
robust MIM extractor
frame rails incorporated into the steel sear housing & locking blocks
frame's "beaver-tail"
revolver-like trigger shape
second spring in the striker assembly (striker return spring, like is used in the 99 series)
the stainless steel guide rod
replaceable grip inserts that allow adjustment of both the backstrap and the palm swell dimension

Now I wouldn't want all of those - but some are very nice indeed.

Glock USA told Glock Austria YEARS ago (when the P99 came out, and the P2000) this should be upgraded on the Glocks as soon as they could.

Glock Austria, as most German/Austrians do, insisted they knew better, i.e you'll take what we make as it is perfect.

They lost enough $$$$ over the M&P and XDm & other polymer guns which had these features suddenly the Glock Perfection became Glock Perfection version 4.0.

Glock Perfection version 4.0 solved very few of the problems.

I owned a Glock, have for a dozen years.

Doesn't mean the company always knows what it's doing.

IMHO M&P and XDm surpassed them because it gave customers what they wanted in a reliable package without costing $700.

Just my opinion.